Qualified Opportunity Zone vs. 1031 Exchange: Which is better?
Whether selling stocks, real estate, or a business, capital gain taxes is a looming concern for many investors. Today we will discuss two ways the US Tax code provides to avoid or eliminate the capital gain taxes legally, i.e., Opportunity Zone and 1031 Exchange.
Section 1031 exchanges, also known as like-kind exchanges, have been used by Real Estate investors for many years to swap real estate assets without causing taxable profits. Now, the latest Qualified Opportunity Zone program offers yet another option for deferring and eliminating such taxable gains that can be applied on real estate, stocks, and business sale capital gains.
Both Opportunity Zone and 1031 are useful methods for reducing tax obligations and securing tax-favored investments. One is motivated by a national policy to encourage investment in specific areas, while the other is motivated purely by the interests of taxpayers. One regime is centuries old, while the other is just a few years old.
So, a 1031 tax exchange or a QOZ real estate investment is better? Continue reading…
What are 1031 Exchanges?
Section 1031 of the IRS tax code, the “1031 exchange.” allows investors to swap one like-kind investment for another like-kind. They are entitled to defer capital gains (or losses) that they would have to pay at the time of sale. Its primary goal has always been to allow taxpayers to keep their property savings while avoiding paying taxes on unrealized paper gains and losses. As a result, a like-kind exchange will result in no capital gain.
What are Opportunity Zone Funds?
The new Opportunity Zone program is an investment vehicle developed under a provision of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of December 2017 to encourage investors to put money into economically disadvantaged communities, thereby spurring economic growth. Investing in these communities, known as Qualified Opportunity Zones (QOZ), will provide investors with immediate and long-term tax benefits. Deferral of gain, partial forgiveness of deferred gain, and full forgiveness of any additional future gains are all possible advantages if certain investment conditions are met.
Let’s compare these two capital gain tax saving strategies in a little more detail.
Comparison between QOZ Investments and 1031 Exchange
|1031 Exchange||Qualified Opportunity Zones|
1031 exchanges are currently restricted to mainly real estate.
With the QOZ program, gain from the sale of any kind of asset can be placed into a QOF and receive the tax edges.
|Need to reinvest all pay-off from the sale, including original principal||Need to re-invest ONLY Capital gains from the sale, no need to reinvest original principal|
|No minimum hold period, can sale anytime from one 1031 to other, or exit 1031 completely (which may trigger a tax event)||10% step-up basis after 5 years hold. A minimum of 10 years hold is needed for full tax benefits.|
|Where can they invest?|
|Investors can invest in property in any place within the United States (if the property is domestic property) or internationally (if the property sold is international property)||Investments are restricted to the property in certain areas declared as Opportunity Zones.|
|Timeline to establish replacement or reinvest|
Establish replacement property
within 45 days of sale; all pay-off from the previous sale must be reinvested within 180 days.
|Reinvest qualified capital gains within 180 days of realization|
|No tax till final sale; Appreciation is calculated from the original basis.||
Tax-deferred until sale or 12/31/2026
Full exception after 10 years
|Connection between parties|
|Exchanges could occur between connected parties.||Solely capital gains from exchanges between unrelated parties could qualify for the Opportunity Zone tax edges.|
|Passing to next generation|
|Heirs owe no capital gains tax||
Heirs answerable for delayed capital gains tax*, however not on appreciation
*A strategy can be created to split preferred interest and common interest within estate planning
Documentation and filing: One-time
Need to file a single IRS Form 8824 for the year of the sale of their property.
Documentation and filing: Annual
Need to report annually through IRS Form 8996.
|1031 exchanges don’t need the utilization of a fund. They actually forbid employing a corporation or a partnership as a vehicle through which to invest in property.||QOF investments require that the capitalist invests within the Opportunity Zone through the utilization of a legal entity that is taxed as a partnership.|
Which Is Better : The Final Analysis
The 1031 exchange can provide deferral with no minimum hold period, an investor can stay indefinitely in that investment, but one has to reinvest all proceeds from the sale. While the QOZ program has a restricted deferral period that provides tax-free gains after a minimum 10-year hold and only needs to invest the gain, making the original principal immediately available.
Both 1031 like-kind exchanges and QOZ real estate investments have pros and cons based on individual scenarios. Which program is better would depend on the goals, priorities, and tax planning strategies of each investor. The 1031 exchange is the better choice if an investor’s primary aim is to delay taxes forever and never access the investment capital; but, if an investor wishes to realize investment gains at any point during their lifetime, a QOZ Fund is the better option.
Finally, just like any other investment or estate planning decision, the decision isn’t made solely based on tax considerations but also based on how the investor needs to access and utilize the gain.
Join our Three-part Educational Series to deep dive into choosing the right approach for you.
Too Much Capital Gain?
3 Ways to Save on Taxes Opportunity Zone, 1031 Exchange, and DST
May 20th, 27th, and June 3rd, 6 PM CST
P.S: Think Outside the Stocks does not provide any legal or tax advice. Each individual scenario is different, please consult a pro, lawyers, CPA, or other advisors to decide which vehicle is the best choice for your circumstances.